Posted: 10:32 a.m. Wednesday, March 19, 2014

Gym tells woman she's intimidating guests with 'toned body'

Geovanna Borges
Geovanna Borges

By Claudine Wong

RICHMOND, Calif. —

A Bay Area woman was asked to cover up while working out at a Richmond gym, after staff members say she was intimidating people with her toned body.

Tiffany Austin said she was excited to get back in shape after recovering from a recent car accident. After her doctor told her it was time to start walking more, she took a tour of the Planet Fitness Gym in Richmond.  On Monday she officially joined the gym and was looking forward to her first workout – but that workout lasted a quick 15 minutes.

Austin said things started out well.  She hopped on a treadmill, set the speed to slow, put her earbuds in and started walking. She started to notice others staring at her, and quickly grew self-conscious but she kept on walking.  That is until a staff-member stopped her.

According to Austin that staff member said, "excuse me we've had some complaints you're intimidating people with your toned body. So can you put on a shirt?”

Austin was wearing a tank that showed her stomach and capri-pants and says she didn't see anything wrong with the outfit. She says she was only told not to wear a string tank because of the dress code policy at the gym.

She agreed to wear the shirt, but while the first staff member went to get it she says she was approached by another staff member who also took issue with her body.   Austin says at that point she had enough; she asked for a manager - asked for her money back and left.

Planet Fitness boasts 5 million members and a policy that bans what they call “gymtimidation.”  Its website says members can get in shape without being, "subjected to the hardcore look-at-me-attitude that exists in too many gyms."

The franchise goes even further and has a “lunk alarm” in every gym which sends off a siren if someone drops a weight or breathes too hard or shows any behavior that staff members consider "lunk-like".

YouTube videos show members across the country getting in trouble for that kind of "lunk-head" behavior.

Derek Van Reheenen is the director of the Athletic Studies Center at UC Berkeley.  

He says, “In a lot of ways I think what Planet Fitness is doing is a positive thing. They obviously need to iron out some of these issues but sport in the U.S. is by nature is discriminatory too, it is selective and it is elite."

Geovanna Borges joined the Richmond gym two months ago and says she likes the policies.

Borges says, "it's unfair to show off your body" because it can make other people feel bad.

Management at the Richmond Planet Fitness referred KTVU to the corporate office.  A spokesperson says the company, "strives to make everyone feel comfortable" and says the dress code is at the discretion of the staff and manager.

However, Planet Fitness spokesperson Mcall Gosselin also said if Austin was criticized for being toned or fit then that "is not in line with the Planet Fitness policy whatsoever.”

Austin says she's no lunk-head and she's not a gym rat - and now she's not even a gym member.   She says her 15 minutes at Planet Fitness left her feeling intimidated and harassed, saying the place that promised no judgments did just that.

More News

 
Featured Articles
 

KTVU.com Weather Outlook

Thursday's weather forecast

Thursday Weather Forecast: Cloudy morning

After a cool day, temperatures will rebound a bit Thursday. Low clouds and fog will resurface near the coast and bay Thursday morning.

Thursday on KTVU News at 5

2 Investigates: Getting tough on BART thieves

Car break-ins while parked at a BART station -- 2 Investigates uncovers the tool BART police are using to get tough with thieves.

KTVU on Twitter

2 Investigates

Esther Ionae and son

2 Investigates: Autopsy reports, internal emails offer new details about deadly public housing fire

Internal emails and newly-released autopsy reports obtained by 2 Investigates are revealing new details about a fire in San Francisco public housing earlier this year that killed a woman and her three-year-old son.

The Daily Mix

Photographer captures the softer side of pit bulls

Sophie Gamand

"Flower Power" captures the softer side of pit bulls

Take a look at the latest photography project by award-winning photographer Sophie Gamand.